Alex Hales' decision this week hasn't caused a crisis at Nottinghamshire but has only served to highlight huge squad deficiencies after a number of high profile departures over the past couple of years, with only two new players coming into the squad from outside.
Now that Hales' absence from Championship cricket is permanent, the decision to look for an overseas batting replacement makes a lot of sense but does little to find a substitute for the attack leading wicket haul of James Pattinson last season. Paul Coughlin was a change bowler for Durham and will only serve to paper over the cracks when a structural rebuild is required. Kitt and Milnes will get their chance this season, as there looks to be little alternative but neither has shown that extra yard of pace, that is necessary at the higher level, when bowling at Lady Bay. Last season we had two standout bowlers in the Championship, Pattinson and Brett Hutton, both are no longer in our service. To win championship games we need a bank of bowlers who can take 20 wickets per match collectively, consistently and I'm not sure by September, when we still have a lot of the season to play, we will have that resource.
So which route will Nottinghamshire take?
- The loan market: leasing players from other counties for one or two month periods to bolster a dwindling squad.
Used so effectively by Hampshire in 2016.
- The Kolpak route: waving a cheque book at fringe South African and West Indian squad players looking for short term financial security to make-up our numbers.
- Back the Seconds: hope that some second eleven players that haven't stood out previously, have grown (of course after a lot of hard work over the winter) into proper contenders. Throw them in off the deep end!
- Cross fingers and hope no one gets injured.
What odds can you get on another Andy Carter resurrection?
Does any of it matter, if Harry Gurney's apparent attitude is anything to judge by then the players aren't really backing the competition anymore (which I'm sure isn't the impression he intended to give). We all need to get with the program and lurch ourselves out the 1980s it would appear.
In the years post 2020, will there be a multi-day format game at all, will there still be counties? There certaining won't be specialists able to pick and choose what to play and what not to play because there won't be a choice! But where will the franchises get there players? Who will they know to bid for, to line the pockets of?
There won't be members either, just season ticket holders at best or those that have bought bulk tickets in advance at a generously discounted price. No invested personal emotion of attachment to a club, just an investment in hard cold cash. Kerching!
The system is broke now but the ECB only look to break it some more in the near future, where do we go from here?
I’m really surprised by the ‘’negativity’’ towards the game/club in this piece. I enjoy reading this thread and the opinion of the members/supporters , rest assured under the new Captain the team/players and staff take all 3 comps seriously
ReplyDeleteMany have similar fears Paul not just at Notts. The game is being steered in a direction that goes away from where current supporters want it to go. No one wants 2 T20 competitions with everything else pushed to the margins. Ask people and they'd say give us some proper cricket in the summer. Good luck with the new season.
DeletePaul you have to admit Harry Gurney has been a bit of a Trump on Twitter, blaming cricket supporters for the demise of the game and his comments do give the impression that his heart really isn't in longer game.
ReplyDeleteTo lose one key player is unfortunate. To lose two key players might be considered unlucky. To lose five players of the quality that we have, without much of squeak from the management could be considered negligent.
ReplyDeleteAs a member I have never questioned Notts desire to try to win all 3 comps. However it seems the clubs are being pulled from pillow to post by the ECB with crazy ideas & scheduling. CC & 50 over cricket being marginalised for T20 All 3 formats should be valued equally
ReplyDeleteI could not agree more that’s the way I have always viewed and shall continue to do so
DeleteI am sure all employees at Notts are taking all 3 comps seriously, as they get well remunerated to do just that.
ReplyDeleteI think concern, as opposed to negativity, is where Notts supporters are at here.
Lets face it, first division is a tough gig, and realistically Notts on paper, are not as strong a team as they were at this stage last season.
Some last minute reinforcements, may boost that optimism, if they can be found.
Mark Nicholas's comments, echo the concerns of many, for "over egging" the fashionable clamour for more T20 type comps to the detriment of all other types of cricket.
Apart from the Ashes, even test cricket is now somewhat of an irrelevance throughout the world. which for traditionalists, is a sad indictment on the state of the game.
There are very powerful people in cricket now demanding action is taken to save First Class Cricket. They, and we the fans, need to demand @ecb act on this. 2018 scheduling in Eng/Wales is terrible, 2020 outline catastrophic, we need new thinking. T20 is only part of cricket
ReplyDeleteI can understand why players might want to focus on white ball cricket only.
ReplyDeleteThe reality is that white ball cricket offers far more opportunities in the modern game. as a country player, pursuing red ball cricket might lead to a call up to the Test game, but it is a hard road and many fail after only a short stint in the England side (especially).
White ball cricket offers at least two domestic formats, franchise leagues at many different levels at home or around the world and two international formats - there is simply much more opportunity. I think that for red ball cricket to survive in the medium term it needs to offer more to would-be specialists.
He’s right. Side is w*nk. Patterson got promotion on his own really and we now have no bowling and batting severley depeleted
ReplyDelete2017 CC2 Hales scored 424 runs (218 in one inn) Pujara ave 27, Hutton 16, BTaylor 24, Lumb 32, Smith 30. Whereas remaining players Mullaney 41, Patel, 53, W Root 50, Wessels 48, Broad 42, Ball 34, Wood and Carter 33, add Coughlin, Nash and Taylor the future looks bright.
ReplyDeletealthough a bit thin
DeleteChris Nash average 27.52 in 12 games in D2 last year
DeleteI doubt anyone thinks it will be a walk in the park, Least of all the Notts players, There is little point in thinking about who has left,retired, We need to concentrate on who is playing for the club now and give them our full support.
ReplyDeleteNotts should have been more proactive with recruitment. It appears all eggs are now in the T20 basket.
DeleteFingers crossed that no one picks up an injury in 4 dayers because there's no spare batsmen for that format.
Is Ross Taylor the answer?
ReplyDeleteWell that remains to be seen in CC Pace Bowling looks ok Lots of experience Think we’ve given up on a spinner Batting looks bare However Moores built his reputation on nurturing young batsman Root deserves a go Libby under pressure Moores won’t be Read
DeleteGood point re: Moores' nurturing skills
Delete