29 October, 2020

Tough Job Filling the Void

 


FILLING THE OPEN VOID

 

After the loss of the influential, and successful opening pairing of Darren Bicknell (2006) and Jason Gallian (2007), Notts have strained to fill that void.

On the staff at present we have got several who have risen to the challenge. Indeed, Steven Mullaney has made a fair job of opening, when others cowered away and has done particularly well at the “testing” Trent Bridge. The current incumbents, Ben Slater and Haseeb Hameed* show plenty of promise for the coming seasons, fingers crossed they do succeed. In match situations, I’m sure that Ben Duckett or Joe Clarke would make good stand-ins, if they haven’t already done so, in their limited Nottinghamshire careers, already. So, at the end of a fraught year there are positives signs in at least in that department for Notts CCC, giving us all hope for the future.

Since 2007, striving to fill that void left by behemoths Gallian and Bicknell, many have given it a try and many have settled into a batting position outside the firing-line of the top two, whilst others have fallen by the wayside. Popular Riki Wessels would and could bat anywhere in the top six or seven, when at his peak, but ultimately shied away from opening at Trent Bridge in the first class game, which cemented Steven Mullaney into his makeshift role. Michael Lumb, Hales’ opening partner in the limited overs game, preferred three with the red ball and so Jake Libby arose to be a prolonged candidate as partner for the volunteer Mullaney. Libby played 48 matches over six seasons, scored 4 tons and averaged just less than 27 – not exactly nailed-it, had he?

Nottinghamshire supporters will recall that the negotiating powers of Mr Newell have sought to out-source from overseas on occasion an opening batsman, or four! All good, all successful and all popular moves, but none of them long term. Alas. Hashim Amla, Kraigg Brathwaite*, Ed Cowan* and Phil Jaques all evoke positive memories for Notts members. Out-sourcing has been Mick’s hallmark; who can forget, but many would wish to, the dynamic duo of Will Jefferson and Matt Wood*? Or, the much maligned, Neil Edwards whose top score, and only ton for Notts, was 195 off the Loughborough students; he had 24 matches and averaged 24. Others too have come and gone; the latest being Chris Nash and before him there were Karl Turner*, Scott Newman* (a loanee) and Greg Smith*. Brendan Taylor, International opening batsman, who was a bit of a coup for Newell, the Zimbabwean did a good job for Notts in all formats but didn’t do it as an opening bat too often.

Homegrown Bilal Shafayat scored three centuries during the period post-2007, on his return from Northamptonshire, and averaged 30 before his final release. Then again there’s always Alex Hales, still on the staff with thirteen centuries to his name in Notts FCC colours, who doesn’t wish to add to that total, disappointingly.

One other name stands out, a product of the academy, a former England u19 international who had four years with the Notts senior ranks, but never got a real shot at the job playing just three games over that period, Sam Kelsall*. Player pathway and youth development not being a hallmark of Mr Newell’s career.

I’m sure others will remember more names that have tried or been tried in that position by Notts since 2007, perhaps for just one game but as the catalogue of names above portrays, “it’s a tough job, but someone has to do it”. DG

* denotes never scoring a ton for Notts

8 comments:

  1. Peter Wynne-Thomas did a wonderful article, 10 or so years ago, on Notts opening duos records from the very start

    Darren and Jason had the best record by some way. Robinson and Broad Snr were second I think

    To be fair, the early heroes batted on some very difficult wickets

    Our openers for BWT did very well and seem to be just what we need

    Steve Mullaney did a fine job and he and Jake often posted 50 or more, but the latter did not then go onto a big scote in those days

    I remember Paul Franks scoring well as an opener in one season, but was that pre 2007 ?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Svensson JohanssonThursday, 29 October, 2020

      Yes, I can also recall Paul Franks AKA "The General" opening the batting with Paul Johnson in the old 40 over Sunday league, or a similar reincarnation of it, when the teams started wearing coloured clothing in these games and when teams explored the option of "pinch hitters" at the top of the order. Not surprisingly this concept was abandoned as they were nearly always up agains opening bowlers of International experience which was too big a test for lower order batsman, no matter what the format was. Also heard Trescothick saying he would never have signed for Notts to open on those surfaces or overheads at that time. Since the new drainage system was intoduced coupled with the ground being improved the word on the street is that the ball doesn't swing as much these days so possibly not quite as difficult to open as it used to be ? Also, Mick could always throw in a "result pitch" that was always going to end in 2 and a bit days when he got desperate to a result and in addition for the request for early season matches at home(as our strength once was clearly the brilliant seam bowling, Siddy, Shrecky, PattinsonD, Adams etc we had at our disposal) it's been a difficult place to open for many years now

      Delete
  2. The main difficulty in batting at TB seems to be over-clouded conditions in the mornings - hence Broad's amazing test Match haul. For many years now Notts have failed to 'grow' a good and consistent opening partnership.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Paul Franks opened for a good slice of the 2010 Championship-winning season (including the last game at Old Trafford). That year, in saving our bacon given the ongoing problems outlined above, taking responsibility and showing his dedication to the cause and no little skill, he proved himself to be the Western Liberal Democracy of Notts opening batsmen - that is he was the worst opening partner for Alex Hales, except for all the others.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember that now, Franksie taking one for the team. It's odd how a mediocre opening bat, as Newell was, has consistently failed to find a successful opening pairing under his own stewardship.

      Delete
  4. We need another home grown Reg Simpson! An elegant classy player who scored a vast amount of runs opening for Notts ( in excess of 25,000?)
    I saw Mick Newall opening for Notts on many occasions . It was tantamount to watching paint dry ( sorry Mick!)
    He was seemingly happy to score at a rate of one run an over regardless of the match circumstances.
    ”Pasty Harris was a prolific opener for Notts over quite a few seasons . Think he scored over 2,000 runs for us in more than one season?
    In these dark , miserable and pretty dangerous times we have our memories to keep us happy.
    Did Sir Garfield ever open for Notts?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think he did v Lancashire in early days of John Player League when rain meant Notts needed 60 to win in 10 overs in the pre DLS days of just run rate

    Lancashire had made a big scote, but Notts won, and a win is a win !

    ReplyDelete
  6. I saw a couple of early John Player Sunday matches on the actual John Player sports ground bordering Aspley Lane . From what I remember the games werent taken too seriously and there was a carnival atmosphere . R

    ReplyDelete

Please share your thoughts...